Platform Access a Civil Right? Think Again

A recent article in Human Events a conservative organization bemoans how modern social media platforms are censoring “Paul Joseph Watson, Laura Loomer, Alex Jones, and Milo Yiannopoulos were permanently banned from Facebook and Instagram. “.  Will Chamberlain make the error by comparing what big social media is doing to the civil rights movement.

The article makes the argument  that could have been  made  by any leftist  or  fascist. It shows  how for  statist conservatives have gone in purging  Reagan’s ideas of liberty and  limited government from  their vocabulary.  For example:

“Platform access is a civil right.

You should now have the same right to speak on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram that you do in a public park.”

“Free Speech is more than the First Amendment, which only protects you from the government infringing on your rights. In 2019, that is woefully inadequate. Access to the large social media platforms – Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram – is a prerequisite to meaningful free speech in 2019.”

“Conservatives should focus on passing legislation – at BOTH the state and federal levels – that protects all citizens’ access to large social media platforms on civil rights grounds. Access should be forfeitable only if one engages in unlawful speech on a platform.”

From  Platform Access Is A Civil Right, By Will Chamberlain  on May 3, 2019

Legislation, Judicial activism? This is something I would expect from the mouth of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Has conservatism fallen  into the statist pit, I believe so.


First, let get one thing straight, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter regardless how statist politicians on both side try to redefine it, are private  companies. The First Amendment does not apply; in addition, their size, being  public  company has no bearing. Second, rights do not  trump rights. The freedom of speech and of the press does not trump Facebook private property rights.

So how we got in this mess? Answer, conservatives allowed the centralized control of media by social media platforms. It was not the case in the early days of networking.  I started in early 1990’s on bulletin boards. While we did of big platforms  like CompuServe, Prodigy and American Online, most media was distributed by individual Bulletin Board Systems. There hundreds of BBS around the county no one group could control them all. If one did not like a BBS, one could start their own BBS; all it took was a PC, software, modem and a telephone line.

Then we saw creation of the internet with personal web pages, content management systems, and blogs.  Again, these systems  were decentralized in nature, running in individual servers. One can link their page via web rings. All one had to do is buy server space or turn a used  PC into a server using Apache. Then  came the Zuckerberg, Twitter and Goggle with the utopia of social media communities.  Conservatives were too quick to surrender their independence by laying their continent at the feet of Facebook and big social media, but soon we learned the so utopia is really a dystopian network as the big three social media companies excerpt control over media.

The solution is not  statisism by bruit though force legislation  and Judicial activism, violating the non-aggression principle. The solution is decentralization not giving Facebook control over our content.  We need to back away from social media. For example, this  post on my blog is using WordPress on a server. Facebook has no control over my site. Other conservative sites have moved to other social networks, like Conservative- Libertarian Fiction Alliance had moved  their content to MeWe from  Facebook. Others have  exploring  social  media  alternatives like using Blockchain.  Because a Blockchain is decentralized, running on many servers, no one person or group can control the  social the media database.

Finally, conservatives can do better in not giving cause to be banned. I often say never give a sucker a break. Alex Jones, and Milo Yiannopoulos are much in fault by their inflammatory  rhetoric. We need to lean to argue with  logic and self-restraint, not giving social media a cause ban an account or delete a post.

Stoical media is  private property, regardless they are jerks about it. Government is not the solution. Stop putting all your eggs in the same big social media baskets, and keep your nose clean.  Find an alternative to Facebook and Instagram.

About Scatcatpdx

I am just an average Joe living in the People Republic of Portland Oregon. I was a Republican Precinct Person for Washington County, and campaign volunteer. Now I am a IDKWIA (I Don't Know What I Am). I am a bible believing Christian who is Calvinist and Reformed in my theology and Anglican in worship and practice. My other interest are music (classical and world, Progressive Trance), drawing, and Fury Fandom, I consider myself a furry lifestyler.. I am a Ham Radio operator.
This entry was posted in Media, Politics and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.